fbpx Press "Enter" to skip to content

Timothy Hill arrested after he tied up 75-year-old neighbor then stole his car, money

Last updated on September 1, 2021

A Titusville man is accused of demanding money from his 75-year-old neighbor and then duct taping his hands and feet when he declined, according to Titusville police.


According to the arrest report, the victim’s neighbor, Timothy Hill, 39, knocked on the Cashew Cortway home door Feb. 7 and proceeded to ask for money because his wife has left him and he wanted to check into a rehab facility.

The victim told investigators he did not want to let Hill in because he already owed him money but the suspect pushed passed the victim knocking him to the floor.

Hill then proceeded to order the 75-year-old to put his hands behind his back but he was unable to because he injured his shoulder when Hill knocked him over, according to the report.

The victim said Hill then tied his hands and feet with duct tape the suspect had with him.

Talk of Titusville will always be free to access.
If you love what we’re doing, please consider becoming a monthly Supporter HERE.

Hill took $105 from the victim’s pockets, two cell phones and demanded the victim give him his gun, according to the report. The victim said he did not have a firearm but only a replica of an antique firearm.

During the home invasion the victim was bound and laying on the floor, according to the report.

Hill then went into the victim’s kitchen took his prescription medication and grabbed the victim’s car keys before leaving in his car, police said.

The victim said he was left tied on the ground but was able to free his hands and call 911. When police arrived he was still taped by his ankles. The victim suffered several marks and bruises as well as an injury to his knee and was taken to Parrish Medical Center, according to the report.

Hill’s estranged wife told police he also approached her for money on Feb. 7 but she told him no because they were separating and she wanted him out of the house. She told police Hill had been alone at their home because she took their children and left.

Hill was arrested Wednesday at the Winn-Dixie on Harrison.

Hill is charged with:

Battery on a Person 65 or older

False Imprisonment

Grand Theft of a Motor Vehicle

Robbery Home Invasion with a Weapon

Hill was booked into the Brevard County Jail and ordered held without bail.

Michael Lynch
Author: Michael Lynch

Raised on the Space Coast, I want to keep North Brevard informed of what's happening. Send Tips / Story Ideas to TitusvilleMedia@gmail.com

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply